Social Media Decides The Election

When Platforms’ Free Speech Beats Yours: The NetChoice Cases and Election Season

In the NetChoice cases that reached the Supreme Court in 2024—Moody v. NetChoice (challenging Florida’s law) and NetChoice v. Paxton (challenging Texas’s law)—the trade group representing major tech platforms argued that social media companies have their own First Amendment rights. Those rights, the argument went, include the power to decide what content appears, what gets amplified, and what gets removed.

The Court’s majority, in an opinion by Justice Elena Kagan, largely agreed with the core of that position. Compiling and curating third-party posts—ranking them, labeling them, or taking them down—is expressive activity. Forcing a platform like Facebook, YouTube, or X to carry material it does not want to carry, simply to “balance” viewpoints, interferes with that expression. Texas’s stated interest in changing the mix of speech on major platforms was not treated as a valid reason to override the platforms’ editorial choices.

That legal outcome has practical effects during elections. Platforms can down-rank, fact-check, limit the reach of, or remove posts and accounts they decide violate their rules. They can also boost other content. Critics call this selective treatment election interference: certain voices are quieted while others are promoted, all under the banner of the platforms’ free-speech rights. Because those rights were held to take priority over individual users’ desire to speak on the same platforms, the companies faced little legal pushback for those choices in the United States.

Speech restrictions are not limited to governments in Russia or China. They can come from political parties that pressure platforms, from government officials who contact companies behind the scenes, or from private actors who want a particular candidate or party to win. A business executive, a large advertiser, or a donor with influence can encourage or reward moderation decisions that favor one side. The mechanism is the same whether the pressure comes from a foreign state, a domestic political machine, or a company protecting its preferred outcome: certain speech is made harder to see or is removed altogether.

What if the balance had gone the other way—if individual users’ free-speech claims had prevailed over the platforms’ editorial rights? Platforms would likely face a steady stream of lawsuits from people whose posts were limited or removed. They would have to defend every moderation decision in court or pay settlements to avoid the cost and risk. At the same time, states or the federal government could more easily dictate what must be allowed or how content must be ranked. That is the trade-off the NetChoice litigation highlighted: stronger platform control means private companies set the rules with limited public oversight; stronger user rights mean more litigation and more government involvement in deciding what stays online.

The cases did not fully resolve every detail—they were sent back to lower courts for further analysis of the facial challenges—but they established a clear principle. On the largest social media platforms, the companies’ right to shape the conversation has so far been treated as outweighing the average user’s right to be heard there. That principle is what allowed the moderation patterns of recent election cycles to continue largely unchallenged in court.

Leave a Reply